Search
Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore My Properties
Light-filled coastal living room with an ivory sofa, oak coffee table and quiet fireplace wall, overlooking a late-autumn garden.

What Happens to a New Buffalo Rental Permit When the House Sells

November 19, 2026

"A permit is terminated when the property to which the permit applies is conveyed to another party." That line comes from Section 11-3 of the City of New Buffalo's short-term rental ordinance.

City permit terms and renewal

City permits are short-lived to begin with. Under Chapter 11, a short-term rental permit expires one year after it's issued. It also ends on conveyance or revocation. The code also says: "A permit that expires or is terminated upon the conveyance of the property can be renewed so long as the application is submitted within 12 months of expiration or termination."

That renewal is not a formality. The same section says "the renewal process shall be subject to the same requirements as the initial application." The ordinance also bars issuing or renewing a permit unless the owner is current on all property taxes, utility rates, fees and special assessments owed to the city. Even then, a permit is granted only "to the extent permits are available in the pertinent zoning district at the time of the application."

Short-term rentals in the residential zones

Ordinance 253, which took effect November 23, 2021, prohibits new short-term rentals in R-1, R-2 and R-3. Article 9 of the city zoning ordinance addresses nonconforming uses, including units "that existed and were registered under Chapter 11 of the Code of Ordinances as of November 23, 2021."

The rules developed in stages:

  1. April 15, 2019: Ordinance 237 required short-term rental permits. According to the Sixth Circuit's case summary, there was no cap on the number of permits at the time.
  2. May 2020: The city imposed an eight-month moratorium on permit applications and extended it for another eight months in December 2020.
  3. May 2021: Ordinance 248 added requirements for obtaining, maintaining and transferring permits.
  4. November 23, 2021: Ordinance 253 took effect, prohibiting new short-term rentals in the residential districts.
  5. Late 2023: The Sixth Circuit affirmed judgment for the city in a homeowners' challenge, as Michigan Lawyers Weekly reported. The court found the plaintiffs had no protected property interest in permits they hadn't obtained before the moratorium. Courthouse News covered the ruling in December 2023.

The amendment would delete the renewal sentence

The agenda packet for the City Council's October 19, 2026 meeting included a first reading of an amendment to Chapter 11, Section 11-3. City Manager Darwin Watson's memo said the 12-month redemption period after a conveyance or revocation is "proposed that this redemption period be removed from the ordinance, as currently codified." In the draft ordinance text, the three ways a permit becomes invalid stay the same: expiration after one year, termination on conveyance and termination on revocation. The renewal paragraph that follows them is gone.

Harbor Country News reported that the proposal was removed from the October 19 agenda. Council members said it would come back at a future meeting and pointed the public to the city's website for details. As written, the amendment is still a proposal. For anyone with a city property under contract, the council's agendas on the City of New Buffalo website show where it stands.

Across the line, a township moratorium

New Buffalo Township is a separate jurisdiction with its own rules. As quoted by Harbor Country News, the township's licensing rule says: "No license may be transferred by the holder. New owners must submit a new application."

On Monday, October 26, 2026, at a special meeting called for 8 a.m., the Township Board of Trustees approved a one-year moratorium on new short-term rental licenses. Supervisor Michelle Heit told the paper the township acted quickly because "we didn't want a lot of people rushing to apply for short-term rentals after hearing the township was exploring the matter." In an interview with WSBT, Heit said the pause doesn't affect current permit holders or the renewal process. She also said the township wants to consider adding short-term rentals to its zoning ordinance, including where they would be allowed. The township held a town hall on the topic on November 9 at the New Buffalo Township Public Safety Building.

City of New Buffalo New Buffalo Township
Term One year from issuance 36 months from approval
Pending change Proposed amendment would remove the 12-month renewal window One-year moratorium on new licenses approved Oct. 26, 2026
Other limits Ordinance 253 prohibits new STRs in R-1, R-2 and R-3 One STR unit per parcel

Why the township is taking a closer look

The township's master plan, as WSBT quoted it, says "over half of all housing units in New Buffalo Township are used seasonally, or for recreational use." Heit said complaints from full-time residents about disruption had been increasing "in many areas of our township, even in rural areas." The same plan projects that the township will need 128 new homes by 2030. Both the city and the township are now reworking rules for the same housing stock. A seller who markets rental history and a buyer who pays for it are both relying on rules that are changing this fall. We covered a similar dynamic, where a rental cap rather than location drives pricing, in our Three Oaks short-term rental post.

This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm how these ordinances apply to a specific property with the city or township and with your own attorney.

If you're weighing a New Buffalo home or preparing to sell one, Joy Schwarting can help. Schedule a Consultation.

Follow Me On Instagram